Saruman vs gandalf in the book

R tolkiens middleearth saga and peter jacksons liveaction adaptation of the books respectively. But in reality, gandalf has asked radagast to use his bird and beast friends to get news of the nazgul riding through middleearth. Saruman is the fallen white wizard and one of the istari, five maiar who came to arda in human form to help in the conflict against sauron. Gandalf and saruman were central characters to tolkiens lord of the rings saga. Sarumans undoing in the fellowship of the ring is his own arrogance. When the istari arrived in middleearth, they were as emissaries from valinor. Gandalf refuses, and saruman imprisons him at the top of his tower. How is gandalf the white a significantly more powerful figure than. Gandalf stood in the middle of the span, leaning on the staff in his left hand, but in his other hand gl. Lotr why was gandalf the white more powerful than saruman. In ta 2851 the white council met to decide on whether to act on gandalf s discovery that the necromancer was actually sauron and was at dol guldur, but saruman dissuaded the others from taking action, claiming that the dark lord was defeated and could not regain his full strength.

Leaving saruman bitter, alone, and alive in his tower, bereft of his power and his magical toys, gandalf is given an important moment of his own in the book. This happened in the books, gandalf showed up and broke saruman s staff. When i read the books the main feature that seemed to stand out the most as. Feb 16, 2017 an in depth analysis on the plot and character changes between the lord of the rings books and their movies for the character saruman. The took the guise of wizards, and saruman and gandalf rank as the most well known and powerful of the order. Saruman is the head of the white council, a group of elves and wizards formed to contest the power of sauron. Can you tell one version of middle earth from another in our lord of the rings book vs. Thorins adventure is only one of the many concerns of the wizard, and tolkien introduced gandalf as exactly the type of character who is involved in a lot of stories elrond, too. Whether or not they have actually read harry potter or the lord of the rings, there cant be many people who can claim ignorance as to. The books make clear that saruman tricks gandalf and imprisons him in. While dumbledore vs voldemort in the ministry is amazing. Tolkiens famous trilogy the lord of the rings is not only a depiction of good versus evil, but a depiction of the corruption of magic and power.

But i was actually referring to gandalf vs saruman in that tower. Nor would he have been able to face down saruman, as originally saruman had. If, in the future, someone else makes another hobbit film they may take the story in a different direction. Due to constraints of the film, saruman does not make an appearance. Sarumans jealousy of gandalf began even here, when varda said of gandalf, who went as the third istar that he was not the third. He is a main character as well as one of the main heroes in j. Saruman s power was destroyed before his plans could come to fruition, and he was killed when.

Like his fellow wizard gandalf, he is a maiar, an angelic being sent to middleearth by eru, tolkiens analog for god. Dec 22, 2002 they added the battle to the movie to be dramatic. Many other people have had this same question and many discussions have been conducted online. However, saruman was a being of pride, and was intensely jealous of his fellow wizard gandalf. Gandalf leaves a letter to frodo urging his immediate departure with barliman butterbur at an inn in bree, and heads towards isengard. Its a bit perplexing since saruman is a stone cold baddie in lord of the rings, and many of you may be bustle. Apr 06, 2020 saruman resembled gandalf not only in appearance, but originally also somewhat in deportment, but unlike gandalf, saruman was proud, even haughty. The decision to include saruman, radagast, and galadriel in the events of the hobbit is reasonable, in my opinion. Why does gandalf say he is saruman when he comes back as. Same with the hobbit movie, when bilbo is the one to keep the trolls befuddled until dawn instead of gandalf. Gandalf has no trouble driving off several others at once while minas tirith is under siege. Gandalf didnt know this, but saruman did, which is why saruman was always suspicious of gandalf. Guide to the lord of the ringscharacterssaruman wikibooks. Nov 25, 2014 at least in the book it gives gandalf some depth.

At the beginning of the third age, a maia of aule the smith was sent alongside four other maiar by the valar and became humanlike wizards to aid the races of men and elves against sauron should he return. Early in the fellowship of the ring, the wizard gandalf describes saruman as the chief of my order and head of the white council. In this series we perform bvm or book versus movies for the. He saw himself as the most powerful of the istari, expressing clear contempt for radagast the brown, patronising tolerance of the wise and elves, and sheer disdain for men.

Eventually, saruman allied himself with sauron, hoping to betray him once he had learned his weakness so he could establish himself as ruler of middle earth. White council the one wiki to rule them all fandom. They collaborated with lotho and otho sackvillebaggins to take over the shire, and also hired human thugs to help. The staff rattled and split asunder in saruman s hands, and the pieces of it fell scattered at his feet.

There saruman reveals his true intentions, urging gandalf to help him obtain the ring for his own use. Gandalf is a very old, very wise and very powerful wizard and one of the ainur who entered the world of arda at the dawn of creation. An indepth analysis on the plot and character changes between the lord of the rings books and their movies for the character saruman. Saruman isnt mentioned by name in the hobbit, however, we do hear about the white council. Each went their own way to prepare for the second coming of sauron, and saruman took to the book, studying the dark magics in the hopes of discovering a way to defeat the dark lord.

How did saruman react to first seeing gandalf the white. I dont know how they are going to do the confrontation between gandalf the white and saruman in the movie, but at that point in the book, gandalf was more powerful than saruman. As a result, sarumans choice to join force with gandalf and sauron was a strategic move to further assist himself in increasing his powers so that. He thinks radagast the brown is a complete fool, and so does not worry about the fact that gandalf has spoken to radagast recently. Being thousands of years old, he is known far and wide by all. Saruman the white vs gandalf the white battles comic vine. Plus, if saruman is only facing one ringwraith as opposed to nine, i think the odds swing heavily in saruman s favor. Originally, he was the chief of the wizards and of the white council that opposed sauron. Voldemort vs saruman death battle fanon wiki fandom.

Saruman is killed after his staff is broken by gandalf. In all three cases the set up is the same as in the book movie. He notes saruman s great knowledge of the magic rings created by sauron and by the elvensmiths. Saruman death battle fanon wiki fandom powered by wikia. We try our best to judge which legendary sorcerer is the best wizard, harry potters dumbledore, or the lord of the rings gandalf. In the past decade, the silver screen has brought some of the most epic wizards to life for millions of people throughout the world. In the film, gandalf openly tells saruman that the ruling ring has been found in possession of the hobbits in the shire.

Peters use of elrond and gandalf is far closer to tolkiens intentions than most people acknowledge. Saruman eventually killed both lotho and otho, imprisoning many hobbits, including lobelia sackvillebaggins. Yuzuklerin efendisi lotr gandalf vs balrog facebook. Another example, though its not about magicpower, is when frodo solves the riddle of the doors into moria in the movie, and in the book its gandalf. At the end, gandalf who has missed much of the events at erebor comes back to report that hes persuaded the white council to move against the necromancer, and drove him out of dol goldur. This happened in the books, gandalf showed up and broke sarumans staff. Rosie cotton appears at the beginning of the fellowship of the ring, working as a barmaid at the green dragon inn, where sam has developed a crush on her. Why are saruman, radagast, and galadriel in the hobbit. Rosie does not appear until the scouring of the shire chapter of the return of the king. Saruman was charged to take aiwendil with him to please yavanna, which he did not wish to do, and this led to contempt for the latter wizard. In the books, theoden is not possessed by saruman in the way the movies portray.

Gandalf was always more powerful, or i guess i should say capable of more power, than saruman was. The white council was formed in ta 2463 shortly after the end of the watchful peace. It may well have been the greatest movie trilogy ever, but the lord of the rings films could have been even better by sticking to the source material. The witchking is by far the most powerful of the nazgul. This debate could go on for many pages and fill a book with an endless quirrel see what i did there. Gandalf and saruman are two incredibly powerful wizards, both.

How is it that saruman the white is more powerful than gandalf the. Indeed i am saruman, one might almost say, saruman as he should have been. Fans of epic fantasy can get their fix with either version of lord of the rings, but one thing is certain peter jacksons films differ from j. Feb 26, 2016 the staff rattled and split asunder in saruman s hands, and the pieces of it fell scattered at his feet. Jul 15, 2015 leaving saruman bitter, alone, and alive in his tower, bereft of his power and his magical toys, gandalf is given an important moment of his own in the book. The staff rattled and split asunder in sarumans hands, and the pieces of it fell scattered at his feet. Tolkiens gandalf and saruman in the tradition of shakespeares prospero magister artium christoph hobel term paper advanced seminar english language and literature studies literature publish your bachelors or masters thesis, dissertation, term paper or essay. What would happen if saruman was a good guy, joined the fellowship, and fought the balrog of moria instead of gandalf. Gandalf got upgraded, and saruman had spent much of his power building his kingdom. As a maiar and a ring bearer is gandalf not supremely more powerful than the nazgul.

I sort of figured he downplayed gandalf so that the hobbits would shine more. In the book, after being flooded out of isengard, both saruman and wormtongue went west to the shire. With equal rank, gandalf should completely wreck saruman. Yes, there are some canon tolkien writings in which gandalf appears, but since many of them were left unfinished by the man himself, were giving this one to dumbledore. Early in the fellowship of the ring, the wizard gandalf describes saruman as the chief of my order and head of the white council that forced sauron from mirkwood at the end of tolkiens earlier book the hobbit. Feb 15, 2019 gandalf, meanwhile, appears in four completed books technically two, if you count lord of the rings as one book like j. Many stories of what was going on in the world were taken out of the council of elrond, which included legolas telling of gollums escape, gloin telling of the messenger from mordor, aragorn telling of his capture of gollum, gandalf revealing saruman s treachery, and bilbo and gandalf telling the history of the ring. Saruman neither magically controls him nor sees through his eyes, so he. Sarumans victory over the grey wizard was entirely a matter of rank. This maia, known in the common tongue as saruman, experienced envy when his fellow maia was.